Toronto, GTA New Home Sales Crashing in November

Toronto’s New Home Sales Slump: What It Means for Buyers, Sellers, and Real Estate Professionals

The Toronto real estate market is telling two very different stories right now. On one side, the resale market is bustling with activity, benefiting from lower interest rates and renewed buyer confidence. On the other, the new home market—particularly condominiums—has hit a historic low, with sales figures resembling a frozen tundra. This stark contrast raises questions about the future of the housing market and its implications for buyers, sellers, and industry professionals.

What’s Happening?

Plummeting Sales in the New Home Market

The new home market in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) is struggling, with sales falling well below historical averages.

• Condo Sales: Condos have been hit the hardest, with just 210 units sold in October 2024. This is a shocking 91% below the 10-year average and represents an 84% drop from the same period last year. It’s not just about low numbers; this stagnation reflects a sector struggling to find its footing.
• Single-Family Homes: Single-family homes, which include detached, semi-detached, and townhouses, performed slightly better with 555 units sold. While this matches last year’s figures, it’s still 45% below the 10-year average, underscoring that this issue isn’t limited to condos.

Declining Prices Across the Board

• Condos: Prices for condos have decreased by 1.6% year-over-year, with the average price now sitting at $1,006,256.
• Single-Family Homes: These homes saw a larger price drop of 4.6% year-over-year, with the average price now at $1,549,416.

Growing Inventory Levels

While sales are declining, inventory is building up. The GTA currently has about 14.4 months of supply available, up from 13.8 months in September. This is well above the healthy market range of nine to 12 months, further reflecting weak buyer demand. Developers are hesitant to start new projects, worried about whether they can sell their inventory.

Why Is This Happening?

High Costs and Weak Demand

The high cost of building homes is at the root of this issue. Construction expenses, along with government fees and taxes, have made it nearly impossible for developers to price homes at levels buyers can afford. This imbalance between costs and affordability has left potential buyers on the sidelines.

Economic Conditions Slowly Shifting

The Bank of Canada has made four consecutive interest rate cuts, which has helped boost activity in the resale market. However, the new home market has yet to see the same surge. Many buyers are hesitant, waiting for further rate cuts or improved economic stability.

Future Supply Concerns

One of the most alarming issues is the long-term impact of low sales today. Housing starts are crucial for future supply, and the current slowdown in building activity is expected to result in a housing shortage between 2027 and 2029. When demand eventually picks up, there may not be enough homes to go around, which could drive prices even higher.

Policy and Government Intervention

Some municipalities are stepping in to address affordability. For instance, the City of Vaughan recently reduced development charges for low-rise homes by 25%, bringing fees down from $94,466 per unit to $50,193. While this is a positive step, it’s not enough to offset broader cost challenges across the GTA.

What Could This Mean?

For Buyers

For buyers, the current market presents both opportunities and challenges. On one hand, declining prices make it a great time to snag a deal, especially on condos. However, the long-term outlook is less rosy. If sales remain low and housing starts don’t pick up, buyers could face reduced options and fierce competition for homes in the future, with prices rising as a result.

For Sellers

Resale sellers are in a strong position right now. With demand surging in this sector, sellers can capitalize on the momentum and potentially fetch higher prices. However, for those selling new builds, the picture is less optimistic. Builders and sellers in the new home market may need to offer incentives, such as reduced closing costs or upgrades, to attract hesitant buyers.

For Real Estate Agents and Brokers

The contrasting markets present a unique opportunity for real estate professionals to showcase their expertise. Agents who pivot to focus on the active resale market may find more opportunities, while those specializing in new homes will need to educate clients on emerging opportunities like falling prices and potential incentives.

For Developers

Developers are facing immense pressure. Rising construction costs and government fees are cutting into profit margins, making it difficult to justify launching new projects. Without significant cost reductions or policy changes, many developers may delay future projects, exacerbating the supply crunch down the road.

The Road Ahead

The GTA’s real estate market is at a tipping point. While the short-term outlook for new home sales remains bleak, there are reasons to be cautiously optimistic about the future. The combination of falling interest rates, a resurgent resale market, and potential policy interventions could reinvigorate buyer demand in the coming months.

However, the challenges are significant. Without addressing the affordability crisis, particularly in the new home market, buyers will continue to struggle, and the housing supply for future generations will be at risk. As the market gradually recovers, all stakeholders—from buyers to policymakers—must work collaboratively to ensure a balanced and sustainable housing landscape.

FAQs About Toronto’s New Home Market

1. Why are new home sales so low in Toronto?
High building costs, government fees, and reduced affordability have made it difficult for buyers to enter the market, particularly in the condo segment.

2. How do interest rates affect the housing market?
Interest rate cuts have made borrowing more affordable, which has driven demand in the resale market. However, the new home market has been slower to respond.

3. Will housing prices continue to drop?
While prices have dropped in the short term, future supply constraints could drive prices up again, particularly by 2027-2029.

4. What does growing inventory mean for the market?
High inventory levels indicate weak demand, which puts downward pressure on prices. However, prolonged low sales could limit future housing options.

5. What role does government policy play in home prices?
Government fees and taxes contribute significantly to the cost of building homes. Policies that reduce these costs, like Vaughan’s fee reduction, can help improve affordability.

6. Is now a good time to buy a new home?
For buyers with the financial means, declining prices present an opportunity. However, buyers should weigh the risks of potential future supply shortages.

Conclusion

Toronto’s real estate market is navigating a delicate balance between challenges and opportunities. While the new home sector struggles, the resurgence in the resale market offers hope for broader recovery. Buyers and sellers alike need to stay informed, adapt to changing conditions, and plan strategically. For real estate professionals, this is a chance to provide invaluable guidance during uncertain times.

‍