Open Bidding for Ontario Real Estate. Is it gaining traction?

Imagine you're at an auction, bidding on a prized antique vase.

The auctioneer calls out numbers, and hands shoot up around the room. You can see your competition, gauge their reactions, and decide how much you're willing to spend based on the other bids. Now, imagine that same auction, but you're blindfolded. You have no idea what others are bidding or how many people you're up against. Stressful, right?

This blindfolded scenario is essentially what home buyers in Ontario have been dealing with for years when it comes to purchasing property. But thanks to a new law, that's all about to change. Let's dive into Ontario's new real estate law on open bidding and what it means for you, whether you're looking to buy your dream home or sell your current property.

The Housing Market Rollercoaster: A Brief History

Before we jump into the new law, let's set the scene. For the past decade, Ontario's housing market has been hotter than a summer day in Toronto. Low interest rates and high demand turned house hunting into an extreme sport.

Meet Sarah and Mike, a young couple looking to buy their first home in the suburbs of Ottawa in 2022. They found a charming three-bedroom house listed at $500,000. Excited, they put in an offer for $525,000, thinking they were being generous. To their shock, the house sold for $650,000. They had no idea they were competing against 15 other offers, some from buyers willing to go way over asking price.

This scenario played out countless times across Ontario, leaving buyers frustrated, discouraged, and often priced out of the market. It's this kind of situation that the new open bidding law aims to address.

What is Open Bidding?

So, what exactly is open bidding? Let's break it down with another simple example.

Imagine you're playing poker. In a typical game, you can't see your opponents' cards. That's closed bidding. Open bidding is like playing poker with all the cards face up on the table. Everyone can see what everyone else has, making the game more transparent and potentially fairer.

In real estate terms, open bidding means that sellers have the option to disclose the details of competing offers on their property to all potential buyers. This includes information like:

1. The purchase price offered
2. Financing terms
3. Conditions attached to the offer (like subject to home inspection)

However, some details remain confidential, such as the names of the buyers and whether their offer is contingent on selling their current home.

The New Open Bidding Law: What's Changed?

In December 2023, Ontario introduced a new real estate law allowing for open bidding as part of the updated Trust in Real Estate Services Act (TRESA). Here's what you need to know:

1. Sellers now have the option to disclose bid details to all potential buyers.
2. Buyers have the right to know how many offers they're competing against.
3. It's up to the seller to decide how much additional information, if any, they want to share about each offer.
4. Realtors can only share information about other offers if the seller instructs them to do so.

How Open Bidding Could Change the Game

Let's revisit Sarah and Mike's story, but this time with open bidding in play.

In this scenario, Sarah and Mike find a similar house listed at $500,000. They put in their offer of $525,000. But this time, the seller opts for open bidding. Sarah and Mike learn that there are indeed 15 other offers, but most are clustered around the $540,000 to $560,000 range. Armed with this information, they decide to increase their offer to $565,000 - still well below the $650,000 they might have paid in a blind bidding war. They win the bid and feel confident they paid a fair price based on the market.

This example illustrates how open bidding could lead to:

1. More transparent and fair pricing
2. Less stress and uncertainty for buyers
3. Potentially lower final sale prices, as buyers are less likely to grossly overbid out of fear

‍

The Bigger Picture: Housing Affordability in Ontario

While the open bidding law is a step towards transparency, it's just one piece of the complex puzzle of housing affordability in Ontario. Other factors, such as supply shortages, population growth, and interest rates, continue to play significant roles in the housing market.

For instance, meet Tom and Emma, a couple in their 30s living in Hamilton. Despite the new open bidding law, they still struggle to find an affordable home due to limited inventory in their price range. Their story reminds us that while open bidding may help level the playing field, it's not a silver bullet for all of Ontario's housing challenges.

Looking Ahead: The Future of Ontario's Housing Market

As we move forward with this new law, it's important to keep a few things in mind:

1. Adaptation Period: It may take time for buyers, sellers, and realtors to fully adapt to the new rules. So far, there hasn't been extensive adoption or traction for open bidding, but that may change as the market picks up
2. Potential for Further Changes: Depending on the impact of this law, we might see additional regulations or adjustments in the future.
3. Market Forces: External factors like interest rates and housing supply will continue to play a crucial role in shaping the market.

Conclusion: A Step Towards Transparency

Ontario's new open bidding law represents a significant shift in how real estate transactions can be conducted in the province. While it's not a complete overhaul of the system, it does offer the potential for greater transparency and fairness in the housing market.

For buyers like Sarah and Mike, it could mean less stress and more informed decision-making. For sellers like Lisa and John, it provides an additional tool in their selling strategy, to be used based on their specific circumstances and market conditions.

As with any new regulation, the true impact of this law will become clearer over time. What's certain is that it marks a step towards a more open and transparent real estate market in Ontario. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, a seasoned property investor, or somewhere in between, staying informed about these changes will help you navigate Ontario's evolving real estate landscape with confidence.

Remember, when it comes to one of the biggest financial decisions of your life - buying or selling a home - knowledge truly is power. And with this new law, Ontario is giving you the opportunity to have a bit more of that power in your hands.

‍