Is Now a Good Time to Buy a Condo?

In recent years, the Canadian condo market has undergone significant transformations, shaped by various economic factors, demographic shifts, and evolving urban landscapes. This comprehensive analysis delves into the current state of the condo market, exploring the crucial role of investors, affordability challenges, and emerging trends that are likely to influence the sector in the coming years.

The Rise of Condo Investors: A Double-Edged Sword

One of the most notable developments in the Canadian condo market is the increasing prevalence of investor-owned units. According to recent data from Statistics Canada, a substantial portion of condos, particularly those built since 2016, are now owned by investors rather than owner-occupants.

Key Statistics:
- In the Toronto Census Metropolitan Area (CMA), 38.9% of all condos were investor-owned as of 2022.
- For condos built since 2016 in the Toronto CMA, the investor ownership rate jumps to 56.3%.
- In the City of Toronto alone, approximately 133,020 out of 328,165 condominiums (40%) are investor-owned.

These figures highlight a significant trend: investors are playing an increasingly critical role in the condo market, particularly for newer developments. This phenomenon has both positive and negative implications for the housing market as a whole.

‍

The Upside: Addressing Rental Shortages

‍
The high proportion of investor-owned condos has become a crucial factor in addressing Canada's tight rental market. With a severe shortage of purpose-built rental units in many urban areas, investor-owned condos are filling a vital gap in the housing ecosystem. These units provide much-needed rental options for individuals and families who are unable or unwilling to purchase a home in the current market conditions.

In Toronto, for example, the estimated 133,020 investor-owned condos likely represent a significant portion of the city's rental housing stock. This is particularly important given the low vacancy rates and high demand for rental accommodations in major urban centers across Canada.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

The Downside: Potential Impact on First-Time Homebuyers

‍
While investor-owned condos play a crucial role in the rental market, there are concerns about their impact on first-time homebuyers (FTHBs). The high proportion of investor ownership, particularly in newer developments, may be limiting the available stock for individuals and families looking to enter the housing market through condo ownership.

However, it's important to note that the relationship between investor activity and housing affordability is complex. Investors often provide the capital necessary for new developments to move forward, potentially increasing overall housing supply in the long run.

‍

Potential Price Impact on Condos: A Cooling Market?

Recent data reveals a notable shift in the Toronto condo market, which could have significant implications for future prices, particularly in investor-heavy areas. As of Q2 2024, condo apartment sales were down 19.8% compared to the same period in 2023, while new listings surged by 36.5%. This imbalance suggests a growing supply of condos, especially as more investor-owned units hit the market.

Investor activity is driving this shift, with a 56% increase in vacant condos listed for sale by May 2024, outpacing the 18% rise in owner-occupied listings. The combination of high interest rates, declining rental yields, and a wave of new condo completions has made many investors reconsider their positions.

This influx of investor-owned units onto the market could lead to downward pressure on condo prices, especially in areas where investors have been dominant. With over 9,951 condos available for sale in the Toronto area—the highest number in recent history—the market may begin to favor buyers, leading to potential price corrections in 2024 and beyond. Investors, who were once instrumental in driving up prices, may now play a key role in tempering them.

‍

The Shrinking Size of Condos: Causes and Consequences

Another significant trend in the Canadian condo market is the decreasing size of units, particularly in major urban centers. This trend is driven by a combination of factors, including changing demographics, evolving lifestyle preferences, and economic considerations.

Statistical Evidence:
- In the Toronto CMA, the median size of condos built in the 1990s was 947 square feet.
- For condos built since 2016 in the same area, the median size has dropped to 640 square feet.
- A similar trend is observed in Vancouver, where median condo sizes have decreased from 912 to 790 square feet over the same period.

Factors Contributing to Smaller Condos:

1. Demographic Shifts: The rise of single-person households, one of the fastest-growing demographic segments in Canada, has increased demand for smaller living spaces.

2. Changing Lifestyles: With the proliferation of food delivery services and changing culinary habits, large kitchen spaces are becoming less essential for many urban dwellers.

3. Economic Pressures Soaring land values, rising construction costs, and high mortgage rates have made larger units increasingly unaffordable for both buyers and developers.

4. Investor Preferences: This is probably the most relevant reason for smaller condos. Smaller units often provide better returns for investors, as they can command higher per-square-foot rents and are more manageable as rental properties.

‍

The Economics of Condo Development is Impacting Prices

Understanding the economic factors driving condo development and ownership is crucial for grasping the current state of the market. Let's break down some key financial considerations:

Development Costs and Pricing
Using Toronto as an example, we can see how development costs translate into market prices:

- The average middle-market condo in Toronto costs around $1,400 per square foot.
- At the current median size of 640 square feet, this equates to a price of $896,000.

These figures illustrate why many new condos are out of reach for first-time homebuyers, especially those requiring more space for growing families.

The Investor's Perspective
For investors, the economics of condo ownership are equally challenging:

- A hypothetical 947-square-foot condo (the 1990s median size) at current prices would cost approximately $1.3 million.
- With a 20% down payment, the mortgage would be $1.06 million.
- Monthly payments on a 30-year amortization at a 4.7% fixed five-year rate would be about $5,200.
- Adding maintenance fees and taxes brings the monthly carrying costs to nearly $6,400, before utilities and other expenses.

These calculations explain why investors often prefer smaller units, which are more manageable in terms of both purchase price and ongoing costs.

Rental Market Dynamics
The rental market also plays a crucial role in shaping condo investment decisions:

- In Toronto, the current average rental rate is around $4 per square foot.
- For a 947-square-foot unit, this would translate to a monthly rent of under $4,000.
- This rental income would result in significant negative cash flow for investors, given the high carrying costs mentioned earlier.

These economics explain why investors are gravitating towards smaller units, which offer better returns and are more aligned with renter demand and affordability.

‍

The Impact of Interest Rates and Construction Costs

The condo market, like the broader housing sector, is significantly influenced by macroeconomic factors, particularly interest rates and construction costs. Recent trends in these areas have had a notable impact on condo development and affordability:

Rising Interest Rates
The Bank of Canada's efforts to combat inflation have led to higher interest rates, affecting the condo market in several ways:

1. Reduced Buying Power: Higher mortgage rates have decreased the amount that potential buyers can afford, putting downward pressure on demand.
2. Increased Investor Caution: Higher borrowing costs may make some investors more hesitant to enter the market or expand their portfolios. In fact, many investors have either put the brakes on investing or are selling off parts of their portfolios.
3. Development Slowdowns: Increased financing costs and slugish sales at current market prices for developers has lead to fewer new projects breaking ground, some projects being halted or paused. This will potentially constrain future supply.

Escalating Construction Costs
The construction industry has faced significant cost pressures in recent years, impacting condo development:

1. Material Costs: Inflation and supply chain disruptions have driven up the cost of building materials.
2. Labor Shortages: A tight labor market in the construction sector has led to higher wages and potential project delays.
3. Regulatory Expenses: Increasing development charges and other regulatory costs add to the overall expense of condo projects.

These factors combine to put upward pressure on condo prices, as developers need to ensure projects remain financially viable in the face of rising costs.

‍

Regional Variations in the Condo Market

While national trends provide a broad overview, it's important to recognize that the Canadian condo market exhibits significant regional variations. Let's explore some key differences across major urban centers:

Toronto
- Characterized by high demand and limited supply, especially for larger units.
- Strong investor presence, particularly in newer developments.
- Rapidly increasing prices, though growth has moderated recently due to higher interest rates.

Vancouver
- One of the most expensive condo markets in Canada.
- Facing affordability challenges, with many locals priced out of the market.
- Efforts to curb foreign investment have had some impact on the luxury condo segment.

Montreal
- Generally more affordable than Toronto or Vancouver.
- Experiencing increased demand and price growth in recent years.
- A growing tech sector is driving demand for urban living options.

Calgary
- More volatile market, influenced by fluctuations in the energy sector.
- Generally more affordable than other major Canadian cities.
- Seeing increased interest as people seek alternatives to high-priced markets elsewhere.

These regional differences highlight the importance of local market knowledge for buyers, investors, and policymakers alike.

‍

The Bottom Line: Navigating a Complex Condo Market

The Canadian condo market stands at a crossroads, shaped by diverse forces including investor activity, changing demographics, economic pressures, and evolving urban landscapes. While challenges persist, particularly around affordability and adequate supply, condos continue to play a vital role in Canada's housing ecosystem.

For potential buyers, investors, and policymakers, understanding these complex dynamics is crucial. The condo market's future will likely be characterized by ongoing adaptation to economic realities, technological advancements, and shifting societal needs.

As urban populations continue to grow and housing remains a critical issue across Canada, the condo market will undoubtedly remain a key focus of attention, innovation, and debate in the years to come. By staying informed about market trends and carefully considering individual circumstances, stakeholders can make more informed decisions in this dynamic and essential sector of the Canadian real estate market.

‍